View Full Version : Forum Censorship
Alkapocino
11-30-2004, 04:17 PM
It's amazing to see over thousands of posting in such a short period of time. :)
But do we really have a freedom of speech to say whatever we want in this forum? Some forumers have encountered me to express their dissatisfaction in this area particularly where their posting were 'indiscriminately' censored and it thwarted the whole meaning of their posting.
Perhaps this thread will give a leeway for those who felt being discriminated to voice out their feelings.
Mods, please do not rush in to censor everything what these people are about to post and I believe we should at least allow them to express their views at full length.
Fulat
11-30-2004, 05:15 PM
I completely agree with "The Godfather". This forum is turning very boringgggggg...... Firstly, lets us relook at the objective of this forum:-
1) Keeping in touch with long lost class/school mates
2) Creating a renewed bonding for those who has left their motherland/kampung in pursue of their goals and dreams.
3) Also to those who has lost touch of their old friends in the course of pursueing their career whereby new friends are made and old friends are forgotten.
4) Alternative mode of communication other than the OPA which meets once a year during CNY and majority of the members are yours and my parents.
5) And most importantly, Tok Kok and have fun!!!
However, if the 'Tok Kok and have fun" objective is removed, this forum will be one boring dead place and bet you, it will not survive to see the light of day and all effort is lost as not everybody is interested to just read a serious post from somebody else whom they have nothing to do with.
The youngest members in this forum are from the class of 98 which effective made them 23yo this year and in another month, they will be 24yo which is way above the legal age of 18. Therefore, a little bit of tolerance in "fun" posting should be allowed to make this forum a more relax and fun place to be in.
Our government has a policy of not cencoring the internet as we are progressing into a more modern society where each of us can think for ourselves, so why are we censoring excessively in this forum when most of us here are a lot smarter than the general Malaysian public? Porn is readily available in the net (check out [EDIT]) but a few [EDIT] and [EDIT] here and there is cencored. I even have post which are censored so heavily until the entire post doesnt make any sense or the main message of the post has been distorted.
To all the moderators, I know most of you are as cheeky as me but dont be too over zealous doing your job. I know most of you are as capable as me to make this place more lively and make those post interesting to read which will attract the number of readership back again and again. Although most of the members will only read your post and not reply, you know that they are enjoying the post and having a good time. Have a look at some post whereby there are less than 30 posting but more than 800 viewing. This clearly shows that the threads are interesting, otherwise, you wont get so many viewings.
Anyway, my suggestion for the moderators that they should keep an eye out for postings which is more detremintal to the overall health of this forum like:-
1) Personal Attacks and online quarrels.
2) Sensitive remarks over religion and race
My 3 cents worth.
Alkapocino
11-30-2004, 05:34 PM
Thank you Fulat for your unselfish thoughts.
Anyone else? :)
fishboy
11-30-2004, 05:50 PM
i support freedom of speech....speeches which can make people laugh although its a little "naughty" .. it will bring up the "playful" atmosphere and surprisingly making me laugh out aloud while "pretending to be working"
TingMS
11-30-2004, 05:51 PM
fishie,
lu anak siaper?
heheheeeee
:cool:
Alkapocino
11-30-2004, 05:54 PM
How about you, happyghost? What do you think of the term "Naughty" as mentioned by fishboy?
ausman
11-30-2004, 05:58 PM
wha-lau weh.... I'm soooo....damm in pressed by ms FU-LAT...(drop pant) so what say you all the SUPER MODEL-ator?
and DA Boss?
I personnally agree that the sensorship board should restrain to level where race, religion, color and personnal attack......must not be in....okie others....
fishboy
11-30-2004, 05:59 PM
fishie,
lu anak siaper?
heheheeeee
:cool:
lu mahu cakap degan bapa gua kah atau gua... bapa tak tahu komputerlah..
ausman
11-30-2004, 05:59 PM
has short bull or 6 inch pipe join us?
Alkapocino
11-30-2004, 06:02 PM
Please be reminded we only have limited time here b4 the mods read this. :D :p :p
Make full use of your time to EYC (Express Yourselves Clearly). Stick to the topic please!!
Thank you.
TingMS
11-30-2004, 06:04 PM
ausman,
tak paham aper you cakap...
TingMS
11-30-2004, 06:07 PM
How about you, happyghost? What do you think of the term "Naughty" as mentioned by fishboy?
Alk,
When you think you are offended,
Is it because people like me make you feel offended or..
you chose to be offended ....
if you chose to be offended, can you chose to be not offended?...
heheheheeee
get what i mean...
:cool:
Alkapocino
11-30-2004, 06:13 PM
Very well said...not too sure the Super Mods understood it?? :confused:
Fulat
11-30-2004, 06:14 PM
When you think you are offended,
Is it because people like me make you feel offended or..
you chose to be offended ....
if you chose to be offended, can you chose to be not offended?...I like your quote, but the problem is the moderator decides for you if you get offended or not? I place nice avatar also kena sound. How lah like that?
Fellow human beings, God almighty is great!! he created man with a brain so that we can design computer and the internet and create a forum, he created fingers so that we can type to express ourselves. Finally, he created women, for us men to admire...but when we express it using the computer, internet and forum which derived from the smart thinking brain he gave us, some smart alec decides to censor it, so, does this make the ppl who has the power to censor is satan, defying God's creation? Need to go church and ask the pastor this Sunday lah.
Alkapocino
11-30-2004, 06:16 PM
has short bull or 6 inch pipe join us?ausman,
tak paham aper you cakap...
Ausman is awaiting a brother joining the forum.
Let's get back to the topic.
TingMS
11-30-2004, 06:18 PM
well, guys and gals,
being da boss has the priviledges....
at the time being, just keep our head high and enjoy our selves....
hehehheeeeee........
:cool:
Alkapocino
11-30-2004, 06:21 PM
Couldn't agree more with happyghost.
We must also give credits to all the Super Moderators in carry out their so called duties so dem well and for daBoss of his brilliant ideas.
Just to remind us this thread is an EYC thread. So don't hold back. :)
fishboy
11-30-2004, 06:22 PM
so, does this make the ppl who has the power to censor satan, defying God's creation? Need to go church and ask the pastor this Sunday lah.[/QUOTE]
will you walk around naked?? somethings kena censored onelah...but not all things..
daBoss
11-30-2004, 06:24 PM
a few points before i respond to your post:
1. i've got to say that of all the members in this forum, i enjoy reading your posts the most (even the big-head director told me that he's amazed that you write so well - ask buffy, turkey and cireria who was there with me when the director said so...)
2. of the members in this forum, your posts are the only ones containing terms that i think is not so healthy (linkinfark's almost at your level :))
3. you know me well enuf to know that my spoken language is almost as colorly as yours
anyway...
Firstly, lets us relook at the objective of this forum:-
1) Keeping in touch with long lost class/school mates
2) Creating a renewed bonding for those who has left their motherland/kampung in pursue of their goals and dreams.
3) Also to those who has lost touch of their old friends in the course of pursueing their career whereby new friends are made and old friends are forgotten.
4) Alternative mode of communication other than the OPA which meets once a year during CNY and majority of the members are yours and my parents.
5) And most importantly, Tok Kok and have fun!!!
i believe that these objectives are currently met.
However, if the 'Tok Kok and have fun" objective is removed, this forum will be one boring dead place and bet you, it will not survive to see the light of day and all effort is lost as not everybody is interested to just read a serious post from somebody else whom they have nothing to do with.
tok kok and have fun doesn't require using the terms you have been using that have been censored.
The youngest members in this forum are from the class of 98 which effective made them 23yo this year and in another month, they will be 24yo which is way above the legal age of 18. Therefore, a little bit of tolerance in "fun" posting should be allowed to make this forum a more relax and fun place to be in.
I oso think that everyone in this forum are adults/young adults. but that doesn't mean that we have to allow using colorful language.
Our government has a policy of not cencoring the internet as we are progressing into a more modern society where each of us can think for ourselves, so why are we censoring excessively in this forum when most of us here are a lot smarter than the general Malaysian public? Porn is readily available in the net (check out [EDIT]) but a few [EDIT] and [EDIT] here and there is cencored. I even have post which are censored so heavily until the entire post doesnt make any sense or the main message of the post has been distorted.
dun want your posts to be edited? very easy - tone down on your use of colorful language (note i did not say DON'T USE - i am saying tone down).
To all the moderators, I know most of you are as cheeky as me but dont be too over zealous doing your job. I know most of you are as capable as me to make this place more lively and make those post interesting to read which will attract the number of readership back again and again. Although most of the members will only read your post and not reply, you know that they are enjoying the post and having a good time. Have a look at some post whereby there are less than 30 posting but more than 800 viewing. This clearly shows that the threads are interesting, otherwise, you wont get so many viewings.
my sincere thanks to all who have been supporting the forum. again, making it interesting doesn't require the terms that you use :)
Anyway, my suggestion for the moderators that they should keep an eye out for postings which is more detremintal to the overall health of this forum like:-
1) Personal Attacks and online quarrels.
2) Sensitive remarks over religion and race
My 3 cents worth.
i believe that this is currently being done. i personally try to read each and every post every day.
==================================
bottom line fulat, this is a public forum. a few rules have to be implemented and enforced to ensure that the place doesn't go out of control. lax a little here and there and how do you draw the line? i believe this place can be colorful and interesting without having to use colorful language... :)
meet up when u are free - i'll buy you a teh-o-ais-limau.
my 10 sen's worth...
Alkapocino
11-30-2004, 06:33 PM
Extremely well illustrated. Anyone else? Where are the MODS??
Anson F-Clef
11-30-2004, 06:36 PM
Hahahahaha Fulatino - ya said that right - !! Wah wah wah.....u also have a hobby of keeping Japanese racequeen photos izit???
Anson F-Clef
11-30-2004, 06:38 PM
I like your quote, but the problem is the moderator decides for you if you get offended or not? I place nice avatar also kena sound. How lah like that?
Fellow human beings, God almighty is great!! he created man with a brain so that we can design computer and the internet and create a forum, he created fingers so that we can type to express ourselves. Finally, he created women, for us men to admire...but when we express it using the computer, internet and forum which derived from the smart thinking brain he gave us, some smart alec decides to censor it, so, does this make the ppl who has the power to censor is satan, defying God's creation? Need to go church and ask the pastor this Sunday lah.
For once you made some kind of sense in your speech, pal.....
Fulat
11-30-2004, 06:39 PM
daBoss has spoken. Sounds so much like a typical gwai low respond which always claims that they have done right and you are given all the freedom in the world to do what you like.
Birdie, time to move on lah, you work in [EDIT] to long already lah. I bet that is how [EDIT] respond to all customers with implementation issues? hahaha....
Anyway, your teh-o-ais-limau is still accepted only thing is when u guys go yam char, never invite me also.
My 30sen ais kacang worth.
Btw, where is that big head director now ah?
TingMS
11-30-2004, 06:41 PM
daBoss has spoken. Sounds so much like a typical gwai low respond which always claims that they have done right and you are given all the freedom in the world to do what you like.
Birdie, time to move on lah, you work in [EDIT] to long already lah. I bet that is how [EDIT] respond to all customers with implementation issues? hahaha....
Anyway, your teh-o-ais-limau is still accepted only thing is when u guys go yam char, never invite me also.
My 30sen ais kacang worth.
Btw, where is that big head director now ah?
Nobody invite you fulat ???
give me a ring....
i will buy you roti prata special....
heheheeeee....
Fulat
11-30-2004, 06:42 PM
Wah wah wah.....u also have a hobby of keeping Japanese racequeen photos izit???
Since I cannot have them in person, I have them in jpeg lah.
Alkapocino
11-30-2004, 06:43 PM
daBoss has spoken. Sounds so much like a typical gwai low respond which always claims that they have done right and you are given all the freedom in the world to do what you like.
Anyway, your teh-o-ais-limau is still accepted only thing is when u guys go yam char, never invite me also.
daBoss, please do not censor this part. We are the witness here.
daBoss
11-30-2004, 06:44 PM
daBoss has spoken. Sounds so much like a typical gwai low respond which always claims that they have done right and you are given all the freedom in the world to do what you like.what to do? every day in the office surrounded by gwai lo...
Birdie, time to move on lah, you work in [EDIT] to long already lah. I bet that is how [EDIT] respond to all customers with implementation issues? hahaha....no lah - i learn all my tricks from you :)
Anyway, your teh-o-ais-limau is still accepted only thing is when u guys go yam char, never invite me also.dun crap with me - everytime ask you not free... next time we meet up in subang jaya i give you a call - would be interesting to have you join in the heated debates between buffy and the director...
My 30sen ais kacang worth. Btw, where is that big head director now ah?Soon... soon... have to start bribing him very soon...
Fulat
11-30-2004, 06:44 PM
Nobody invite you fulat ???
give me a ring....
i will buy you roti prata special....
heheheeeee....
I want chicken curry with real chicken can ah?
Any more offers? I welcome them with open arms.... hehe!!
Alkapocino
11-30-2004, 06:45 PM
Hahahahaha Fulatino - ya said that right - !! Wah wah wah.....u also have a hobby of keeping Japanese racequeen photos izit???
This post will definitely get snipped (and thrown into the Kay Poh Chee Corner) if I am given the authority to do so.
Back to topic please.
We are not done yet as only less than 10% of the forumers have given their views. :)
Fulat
11-30-2004, 06:48 PM
[QUOTE]
dun crap with me - everytime ask you not free... next time we meet up in subang jaya i give you a call - would be interesting to have you join in the heated debates between buffy and the director...[QUOTE]
OK OK!! On! You name the time and place and I will be there, unless, got party to attend with all the jap race queens lah. That time, we will "[EDIT]" the whole world!!
Anson,
You can only drool but I will still not invite you!! hahahaha......
Alkapocino
11-30-2004, 06:51 PM
gees...Boss, I thought we have the deal. You censored Fulat's statement even before I could view it. :(
daBoss
11-30-2004, 06:52 PM
will surely remember to call you next time we meet in sj. just make sure you dun give excuses.
Fulat
11-30-2004, 07:00 PM
gees...Boss, I thought we have the deal. You censored Fulat's statement even before I could view it. :(Show power mah!! Ok lah! I retire for good.....
I learn from our politicians, if cannot talk, then dont talk or face the consequences!!
I think I spend my time surfing porn better lah.
Alkapocino
11-30-2004, 07:02 PM
Come on people, we need to talk. :)
Fulat
11-30-2004, 07:13 PM
Normal ppl dare not speak up because they are afraid of the consequences imposed by the authorities ie. daBoss and his cronies.
Great ppl speak their mind but still face the consequences. But what the heck! Be the first to read the post before the almighty show their power!! hahaha....
Alkapocino
11-30-2004, 07:19 PM
Look at the bright side..you can still post whatever you want. Nobody is stopping you...YET!! :)
Till this point...CENSORSHIP stays.
But I wish to hear more comments.
KoChun
11-30-2004, 08:55 PM
Normal ppl dare not speak up because they are afraid of the consequences imposed by the authorities ie. daBoss and his cronies.
Fulat, maybe you would like to elaborate this statement a little more. I don't really get your point.
A lot has been written and daBoss has given his comments. Meanwhile, all those comments are noted and well said. As of my stand, censorship STAYS, for the sake of this forum.
Fulat, I buy you supper next Monday in Tmn Megah.
Fulat
11-30-2004, 09:04 PM
Fulat, maybe you would like to elaborate this statement a little more. I don't really get your point.
A lot has been written and daBoss has given his comments. Meanwhile, all those comments are noted and well said. As of my stand, censorship STAYS, for the sake of this forum.
Fulat, I buy you supper next Monday in Tmn Megah.Like I have said earlier as well, the respond is nothing more than just taking my comments, twsiting it left a bit and right a bit, like how your bosses answers your questions if they are in the disadvantage which means nothing.
Anyway, my opinion stays the same. So, tell me, what is your defination of censorship? What are the goals of doing so? Give me a good reason and I believe the rest of us will understand and abide by the rule. Otherwise, hell shall break lose!! and the moderators will have their hand's full doing what they like doing best, snipping here and there. Please dont tell us that censorship is to preserve the value of good english as our 'England very powderfull' enuf already.
Btw, your supper offer is accepted provided you stay back after the game lah. Beware, I can eat more than you expect so please define if supper is limited or unlimited helpings? hahaha......
i think that although we are all adults and we all know the words that are being snipped, i still believe that the moderators should snip obscenities. knowing my own leanings, if we were allowed to express ourselves and say whatever obscenity we want to, i certainly would take it to the extreme and so would many of us. then i know that i would get tired of reading the posts because if i want to go look at or read such things, there are porn sites which provide that.
my 2 kupang worth..
Fulat
11-30-2004, 09:39 PM
i think that although we are all adults and we all know the words that are being snipped, i still believe that the moderators should snip obscenities. knowing my own leanings, if we were allowed to express ourselves and say whatever obscenity we want to, i certainly would take it to the extreme and so would many of us. then i know that i would get tired of reading the posts because if i want to go look at or read such things, there are porn sites which provide that.Brader, I think you have not surf enuf porn lah. Porn sites do not post obscene language that much lah, only obscene pictures and videos.
Anyway, enjoy yourself with the following link!! hahaha...
[EDIT]
See, only pictures and no obscenities....
daBoss
11-30-2004, 10:07 PM
1. sila is a sister, not a brader :)
2. in response to your earlier question about why language should be censored: where do you draw the line? it'll just creep and creep and then one day you'll find it out of hand...
3. guys, better post in this thread if you want to - i'll be closing it soon...
Ok....here are my thoughts.....
1) Profanity and language do not make the forum. Content and quality of the threads do. I agree that most of the threads in the General n KPC are cartoon threads. I guess....the thing that we need to realize is that this is a very general forum and therefore, not really appropriate for profanity in some degree.
2) I personally don't care about the language but i am sure that there are some that do.I guess the best solution is to create another specialize section for adults with open mind.Da_boss....would it be possible for you to create a new section called something like "Free Zone" only for members, and post a sign that in that zone that this zone, anything goes. Self censorship will be pratice in that forum. Moderators will only step in if it gets personal.
Sorry Sila, was modifying my thread when you responded to it.
Ok....here are my thoughts.....
1) Profanity and language do not make the forum. Content and quality of the threads do. If the threads are boring, why don't interested parties step up to the plate and chip in some ideas. No point sitting on the sideline and complain.
Most of the threads in General and KPC are cartoon threads anyway.
2) I personally don't care about the language but i am sure that there are some that do.Da_boss....would it be possible for you to create a new section called something like "Free Zone" only for members, and post a sign that in that zone that this zone, anything goes. Self censorship will be pratice in that forum. Moderators will only step in if it gets personal.
dino i agree. also we should remember that while we members are adults, the site itself is open to the public. i don't really want any little kids reading the ACS page and going, eh, what did uncle say there? looking it up and then, what? i liked that when we were kids, we were allowed to be kids and not know the ways of the adult world
take the pantun thread, i have been laughing my ass off on that one. no real profanity pun! i am busily trying not to work and think of pantuns to post...
1. sila is a sister, not a brader :)
amen to that, boss! :)
Ok....here are my thoughts.....
Sorry Sile, was modifying my thread when you responded to it.
no worries takpe.. :) i keep wanting to edit all of the posts here feel like i'm not expressing myself accurately. believe me, i can be as profane (and profound?) as the next person - ask anyone who's driven in a car with me. but where do we draw the line, language wise. it will get out of hand i think. we will want to keep topping each other.
daBoss
11-30-2004, 11:26 PM
[Thread closed] Good discussion...
siewjang
12-01-2004, 11:43 AM
How come no one called me when there's a heated debate on something like this???? Hm... missed all the fun. As daBoss put it in post #19 - tone down; and the word 'tok kok' is allowed as i can see... i'll keep myself noted on that.
Alkapocino
12-01-2004, 11:50 AM
it will be re-opened once daBoss is back to the office. In the meantime, sit back and relax. Our sincere apologies that we overlooked to extend the invitation to the Hijack Queen. :p
siewjang
12-01-2004, 11:56 AM
Alk, don't talk like that make me paiseh only.
ausman
12-01-2004, 12:36 PM
what hijack queen is paiseh.... hmmmm...
ausman
12-01-2004, 12:37 PM
what an interesting thread! gee I was away for less than 2 hours... and the thread closed... gee.... speedy gonzales*
song cm
12-01-2004, 04:47 PM
Yah...me too. Saw them this morning and it was too late....
I totally agreed with Edwin's comments (and not becoz his is the administrator) as some form of moderation is required as this is a public forum. We wouldn't want ppl to view this ACS Alumni Forum as a XXX forum.
But what I would appreciate is the super moderators to exercise some form of common sense before censoring anything. So far they have been doin ok...
cireria
12-01-2004, 07:09 PM
members should exercise some self-moderation - would rather not moderate/edit members' post as it might coz the posts or thread to lose the intended message/effect/whatever...
daBoss
12-01-2004, 07:26 PM
[Thread re-opened due to popular demand - especially Alka and Ah Jang]
KoChun
12-01-2004, 09:09 PM
members should exercise some self-moderation - would rather not moderate/edit members' post as it might coz the posts or thread to lose the intended message/effect/whatever...
This I fully agree. Very well said, cireria.
shortcow
12-01-2004, 10:50 PM
Wah Fulat's 3 cents worth is so long dat i lost focus reading half way thru'. It took me 3 readings ( sori ah Fulat - no offense). But the fact of the matter is i agree wif him in the sense dat if the administrator is gonna sensor my posting until it has no meaning at all, then provide us wif the guideline and save us a lot of streamyx time (might as well chat in other chat rooms and see whether can catch some "featherless chicken").
We are all adults and this forum is not religion oriented, therefore people shd be allow to "play around among frens" especially after a long day at work.
this is my 1 cent worth of contribution.
cheers!
Fulat
12-01-2004, 11:07 PM
Wah Fulat's 3 cents worth is so long dat i lost focus reading half way thru'. It took me 3 readings ( sori ah Fulat - no offense). But the fact of the matter is i agree wif him in the sense dat if the administrator is gonna sensor my posting until it has no meaning at all, then provide us wif the guideline and save us a lot of streamyx time (might as well chat in other chat rooms and see whether can catch some "featherless chicken").
We are all adults and this forum is not religion oriented, therefore people shd be allow to "play around among frens" especially after a long day at work.
this is my 1 cent worth of contribution.
cheers!
Welcome Shortcow! all has been anticipating your entrance.
Anyway, the heck i care about self moderation as I shall continue to write as I please and the moderators has to work extra hard to make sure they check all my post weekly, daily or even hourly without fail to edit my language. They must also do work lah, otherwise give title as moderator for what?
So, for those luck few who are the first to read my post before it is censored, you guys are lucky lah. It is like watching Tarzan many many years ago when Bo Derek was Jane, we all got to watch the video tape and saw her assets in all her glory before my mum consficated the tape (another form of censorship). God knows how many times we rewind and pause. Unfortunately, those days, the VCR player got no zoom and you know lah, this was before the VCD/DVD 5 star movies were readily available and to see a nipple, i tell you, was like watching Rocco Sifreddie [EDITED: profanity] one of his eastern europe chicks!!
Anyway, the last sentence above is going to get snipped very soon, so those of you who can tell me what was the message after it gets censored, wins a cup of teh ping from me!!!
You are right, Fulat... Got your last sentence 4 minutes after you post...
Fulat
12-01-2004, 11:21 PM
You are right, Fulat... Got your last sentence 4 minutes after you post...
To earn your teh ping, tell me in this forum what was the word? or, if you cannot say the word, describe the action!
In order to be discrete, sounds like something to do with "arsenal". :D
Actually no need prove.... I edited your posting-lah....
Voon Chan
12-02-2004, 09:12 AM
[QUOTE=Dino]
Profanity and language do not make the forum. Content and quality of the threads do. I guess....the thing that we need to realize is that this is a very general forum and therefore, not really appropriate for profanity in some degree. QUOTE]
I agree Dino to a great extent. We need quality thread & posting. I know we cannot impose everyone to post only quality material, if we do, no member will remain in this forum.
On the other hand, I agree with Fulat (evnthough I do not have the privilege to read his unedited version of posting) that censorship may distort the true meaning of the posting. If members exercise care in their posting by choosing the appropriate language to express what they want than the issue of censorship does not arises.
This is a fun forum that we would like to continue to share our thought with our friends. A place we can release our tension & have a good laugh reading nonsense posted.
We are all adults, We should not be too sensitive when we read a line or two containing profanity. In our society, it is very common we hear such vulgar words being used in public. We cannot walk up to a stranger and say "You can say that #*%# words. Can we edit what they have said? What then will happen to us? All of us should learn to tolerate one another in a public forum like this. That does not give us the license to be offensive too.
To members & moderators exercise care. Exercise censorship as and when required. I think everyone is doing fine at the moment.
Let me say that, i think i was sleeping when something was censored that caused this thread to be started, so i don't really know what happened.
Personally, i believe every single person should excersise free speech and express how he/she feels. I am not a fan of censorship. I get annoyed by censorship myself. But bear in mind that everyone of us needs to realize that there needs to be a line drawn somewhere when we are talking about a forum this general. This happens to be an alumni forum. Its a GENERAL forum. I don't expect to go to Harry Potter movie and expect those kids taking turns banging the be-jezus out of each other.
If talking about sex is your motivation to come here, then i think you probably chose the wrong place to do it. Heck, there are millions of porn sites with forums you can participate in.
If you stand in the public place and started talking loudly about profanities, you are surely to get stares. But if are in a all-hands-profanity club meeting...by all means, knock yourself out!!! Heck, have a stripper while at it, i don't care!!
Bottom line....feel free to excersise your right to free speech, but please extend some courtesy to others. :)
siewjang
12-02-2004, 11:04 AM
... But bear in mind that everyone of us needs to realize that there needs to be a line drawn somewhere when we are talking about a forum this general. This happens to be an alumni forum. Its a GENERAL forum.
If talking about sex is your motivation to come here, then i think you probably chose the wrong place to do it. Heck, there are millions of porn sites with forums you can participate in.
If you stand in the public place and started talking loudly about profanities, you are surely to get stares. But if are in a all-hands-profanity club meeting...by all means, knock yourself out!!! Heck, have a stripper while at it, i don't care!!
Bottom line....feel free to excersise your right to free speech, but please extend some courtesy to others. :)
Dino has some sense on this. This is not a place to talk about porn. I mean if you are writing and the vulgar word came unspontanously then it's excused. There is the super mods who is out there doing their duty. But if you came in here and just like to talk some XXX on purpose or even post some porn URL then that is too much.
Linkinfark
12-02-2004, 11:28 AM
Dino has some sense on this. This is not a place to talk about porn. I mean if you are writing and the vulgar word came unspontanously then it's excused. There is the super mods who is out there doing their duty. But if you came in here and just like to talk some XXX on purpose or even post some porn URL then that is too much.
On the above quote I would like to 'defend' fulat as knowing him for so long, he's a straightforward guy who uses profanity in his daily conversations. His posting of porn links was just to make a statement to the moderators.
But of course porn urls are always easily accessable which we can PM to one another just to care and share..
Looks like the censorship board will have to work overtime editing our conversations from now on. Fulat, you and I are marked targets! :(
I think some threads are becoming slightly boring and don't really bother to read thru them.. No joke no fun mah..
On the above quote I would like to 'defend' fulat as knowing him for so long, he's a straightforward guy who uses profanity in his daily conversations. His posting of porn links was just to make a statement to the moderators.
But of course porn urls are always easily accessable which we can PM to one another just to care and share..
Looks like the censorship board will have to work overtime editing our conversations from now on. Fulat, you and I are marked targets! :(
I think some threads are becoming slightly boring and don't really bother to read thru them.. No joke no fun mah..
Nah....not marked. You'll just get banned..hehhehehe.....JUST KIDDING!!!!!
I will assumed that people who use profanities are not religious.
How would you feel if you have a forum of sexual content and a religious fella came in and started posting his views with holy religious jargons and quoting verses from his religious books right in the middle of your wild discussion? The argument that he/she has been religious all his/her life so thats how she talks just don't seem to fit the content of that particular forum. I use profanities myself but i surely won't use them in front of everybody.
Linkinfark
12-02-2004, 12:28 PM
Nah....not marked. You'll just get banned..hehhehehe.....JUST KIDDING!!!!!
I will assumed that people who use profanities are not religious.
How would you feel if you have a forum of sexual content and a religious fella came in and started posting his views with holy religious jargons and quoting verses from his religious books right in the middle of your wild discussion? The argument that he/she has been religious all his/her life so thats how she talks just don't seem to fit the content of that particular forum. I use profanities myself but i surely won't use them in front of everybody.
One of my ex colleague used to say - Do not assume, you will make an ass of of u and me... Even religious people swear. In spite of this, everyone have their faith in their religion and beliefs. If a truly holy person come and join our discussion, he/she is always welcome to share his input and ideas. Everyone has their own opinion and this forum is for them to share their views etc..
I myself use profanities moderately also.. Cheers... ;)
One of my ex colleague used to say - Do not assume, you will make an ass of of u and me... Even religious people swear. In spite of this, everyone have their faith in their religion and beliefs. If a truly holy person come and join our discussion, he/she is always welcome to share his input and ideas. Everyone has their own opinion and this forum is for them to share their views etc..
I myself use profanities moderately also.. Cheers... ;)
Just u not me as ass is closer to u. ;)
Linkinfark
12-02-2004, 12:38 PM
Just u not me as ass is closer to u. ;)
Eh.. i got nice ass ok.. :D
cireria
12-02-2004, 12:53 PM
On the above quote I would like to 'defend' fulat as knowing him for so long, he's a straightforward guy who uses profanity in his daily conversations. His posting of porn links was just to make a statement to the moderators.
But of course porn urls are always easily accessable which we can PM to one another just to care and share..
Looks like the censorship board will have to work overtime editing our conversations from now on. Fulat, you and I are marked targets! :(
hello linkinfark and fulat,
perhaps the reason if/why moderators might have marked your posts as targets for moderation is not bcos we like to... but bcos u freaking cowboys want us to! me enjoy tombstone bcos of doc holliday, i'm sure they'd be those who visit this site for the linkinfark and fulat show... "i'm your huckleberry"... come get me you @$$f@*&!^% moderators!!
Linkinfark
12-02-2004, 01:00 PM
hello linkinfark and fulat,
perhaps the reason if/why moderators might have marked your posts as targets for moderation is not bcos we like to... but bcos u freaking cowboys want us to! me enjoy tombstone bcos of doc holliday, i'm sure they'd be those who visit this site for the linkinfark and fulat show... "i'm your huckleberry"... come get me you @$$f@*&!^% moderators!!
Butch Cassidy & The Sundance Kid! We'll come out fighting in a hail of bullets!! Yeeehhaaaaarrrr!
Frankly speaking, we are just partaking in normal conversations which you would probably have at any mamak stall or cafe... Only now we have more participants and some would be just innocent by-readers who enjoy our conversations but don't really join in..yet..
Friends,
Most of you mentioned that we are all grown-ups who can take profanity. Though I do agree on that point, but I do see the need for us to be responsible towards our motherland/kampung... If we continue, swearing/insulting each other with profanity (including posts with vulgar volcabulary), what would non-Sitiawanese (or rather non-ACS Sitiawanese) think of us?
This is not an Intranet... This forum is on the Internet... The general public (including tech-savvy parents/grandparents/sons/daughters from Sitiawan & ACS) will be able to view our posts save for the Underground Thread...
People DO get offended reading profanity... If you dispute me on this fact, do me favour... Speak in your corporate meetings as you would write in this forum... Get my drift?
Please, people... I beg for your understanding to "tone down"... (too much work for me without pay somemore :D)
Fulat
12-02-2004, 05:55 PM
I will assumed that people who use profanities are not religious. How can u say I am less religious than you? From moderator, u suddenly became GOD ah? I believe in God, I believe in his teachings, I help spread his message, I say a prayer of thanks whenever my postings are not censored..Amen!! There you go, so am I less religious than you?
What I can tolerate is the man of GOD swearing occassionally but what I cannot tolerate is a hypocrite(did i spell that right?).
So, saying penis, clitoris, breast...is that a wrong word to use? So, how do we describe a certain anatomy instead of your nose or arm to another person? Is those words are wrong to use, why is it in dictionary? I remember in school, we learn about Faraj and Zakar and buah Zakar, so, somebody made the mistake of not editing it? if is it because Dewan Bahasa dan Pustaka have not appointed the right moderators?
So instead of using the word "fark", can I say "having sex" or "making passionate love"? In the times of Adam and Eve, they were created naked. His ding dong swinging left and right when he walks the face of this new earth. [EDIT]
Anyway, as holy as I would like to be and as decent as I would like to be (like you), can you descriminate me by the way I speak or write? You live in Sitiawan most of your life, so everytime you hear [EDIT], what do you do? Dont tell me you avoided such ppl. Probably you are one of them as well.
Linkinfark, you are the man!!! I would vote you as the "Super Duper Moderator"
Voon Chan, My post got quality and substance or not? Or did the so called vulgarity used to make my point blinded you and the rest into seeing this post as a XXX material?
cireria
12-02-2004, 06:16 PM
Fulat, relak la bro...
Linkinfark
12-02-2004, 06:19 PM
How can u say I am less religious than you? From moderator, u suddenly became GOD ah? I believe in God, I believe in his teachings, I help spread his message, I say a prayer of thanks whenever my postings are not censored..Amen!! There you go, so am I less religious than you?
What I can tolerate is the man of GOD ocassionaly swear but what I cannot tolerate is a hypocrite(did i spell that right?).
So, saying penis, clitoris, breast...is that a wrong word to use? So, how do we describe a certain anatomy instead of your nose or arm to another person? Is those words are wrong to use, why is it in dictionary? I remember in school, we learn about Faraj and Zakar and buah Zakar, so, somebody made the mistake of not editing it? if is it because Dewan Bahasa dan Pustaka have not appointed the right moderators?
So instead of using the word "fark", can I say "having sex" or "making passionate love"? In the times of Adam and Eve, they were created naked. His ding dong swinging left and right when he walks the face of this new earth. [edit]
Anyway, as holy as I would like to be and as decent as I would like to be (like you), can you descriminate me by the way I spead or write? You live in Sitiawan most of your life, so everytime you hear "[edit]", what do you do? Dont tell me you avoided such ppl. Probably you are one of them as well.
Linkinfark, you are the man!!! I would vote you as the "Super Duper Moderator"
Voon Chan, My post for quality and substance or not? Or did the so called vulgarity used to make my point blinded you and the rest into seeing this post as a XXX material?
CLAP CLAP CLAP CLAP CLAP CLAP.. Standing ovation man!
Super Duper Moderator? Cannot lah.. one day on duty kena sepak by daboss liao.. cause too lax... hee hee...
Fulat
12-02-2004, 09:07 PM
daBoss,
You censor the words you dont like enuf lah. As moderator, I think not very ethical to delete the entire paragraph or sentence right? Like that the message distorted already then people think i tok kok and make no sense. The Adam and Eve story got more than just his ding dong but anyway........"sigh".
To all other braders in this forum,
If you want to see my future post in all its glory, be there before the "sek bau mou yeh joh" moderators reach there first.
Anyway, my pledge to the community, I shall continue writing using my brand of engrish, and the moderators can continue do work, otherwise, i think their thankless job also very boring. I can write wherever i want, and they got to come find me!! muahahaha.... who knows, one day, I might not be Fulat anymore but Malat? hahahahaha......
Fulat
12-02-2004, 09:12 PM
Fulat, relak la bro...
Eh? since when I not relak? I always relak wan!! Only lurking around to see which post should receive my 2 sen worth of comments only.
This is forum mah, not chat room. If wanna chat, then use MSN Messenger or call the bugger's phone lah.
Alkapocino
12-02-2004, 10:18 PM
WHAT THE [edited] [mod: clarification - the red lettering was not edited by mods but written by Alka]
Should the underlined word(s) was/were edited, what would you figure it could be?
Shit? Heck? Bloody Mary? Sucks? Bitch? F**k[edited: replaced with stars]?. Just to name a few (bet others would have deeper vocabs than i do ).
I for one have difficulty quessing the missing or edited word(s) and it's truly NOT FAIR for us just to fill in the blanks. Just in case we gathered the wrong word and have a wrong impression on the author. Should the edited word is only plain Shit then by thinking the author could have meant F**k[edited: replaced with stars] it's really demeaning the author and the poor fella will be left at the mercy of the Super Mods. Let's not be the judge and let GOD Almighty be their judge. Please for the sake of the above mentioned, censor the post with great wisdom.
By saying this, I am not an advocator of vulgarness nor profantory nor anything like this. Just want to see freedom of speech is exercised.
Lets' quote the latest example:
Anyway, as holy as I would like to be and as decent as I would like to be (like you), can you descriminate me by the way I speak or write? You live in Sitiawan most of your life, so everytime you hear [EDIT], what do you do? Dont tell me you avoided such ppl. Probably you are one of them as well.
Our dear Super Moderator KoChun, for goodness sake..what is the missing word (underlined) that you have edited. I don't want to be accountable for misjudging Fulat and I can't answer to my God.
I rest my case. :)
KoChun
12-02-2004, 10:51 PM
In school, either primary or secondary, we were taught 'Fill in the blanks' by our school teachers. Even we were tested in the exams. So, use your imagination and fill in the blank with appropriate words.
Fulat
12-02-2004, 10:51 PM
By saying this, I am not an advocator of vulgarness nor profantory nor anything like this. Just want to see freedom of speech is exercised.
How can I not agree with d Godfather, the man with wisdom but without the wisdom tooth.
I for one also do not advocate vulgarity nor profanity. This is the most terrible thing to say to anyone, worst than cursing "pok kai, hang kar ling"!! Anyway, back to the main topic, if I happened to use such word, it is to express myself and have more impact on the intended message. Otherwise, how to can the post be interesting? I rather read Mills & Boon (super duper boring, I rather watch Rocco Ravishes Russia!!).
Therefore, if such words are deem vulgar, rude and what not, then why did the engrish dictionary[edited: sic] have description on all those words? Should be banned by her majesty already right? If you use the encarta dicktionary (available via online dictionary[edited: sic] in MS Office) and type in the work "f**k"[edited: replaced with stars], you get a whole list of explaination and discription. Therefore, it is a legal word and some learned person has spend lots of time studing the meaning of it.
Therefore, does this mean that the some of the member's engrish here is a lot more accurate that those appointed to do the job professionally? Hmmmm..... point to ponder.
Kochun,
You delete somemore, when I play badminton with you again, I'll smash the shuttle(at your)cock!! hehe....
How can u say I am less religious than you? From moderator, u suddenly became GOD ah? I believe in God, I believe in his teachings, I help spread his message, I say a prayer of thanks whenever my postings are not censored..Amen!! There you go, so am I less religious than you?
What I can tolerate is the man of GOD swearing occassionally but what I cannot tolerate is a hypocrite(did i spell that right?).
So, saying penis, clitoris, breast...is that a wrong word to use? So, how do we describe a certain anatomy instead of your nose or arm to another person? Is those words are wrong to use, why is it in dictionary? I remember in school, we learn about Faraj and Zakar and buah Zakar, so, somebody made the mistake of not editing it? if is it because Dewan Bahasa dan Pustaka have not appointed the right moderators?
So instead of using the word "fark", can I say "having sex" or "making passionate love"? In the times of Adam and Eve, they were created naked. His ding dong swinging left and right when he walks the face of this new earth. [EDIT]
Anyway, as holy as I would like to be and as decent as I would like to be (like you), can you descriminate me by the way I speak or write? You live in Sitiawan most of your life, so everytime you hear [EDIT], what do you do? Dont tell me you avoided such ppl. Probably you are one of them as well.
Linkinfark, you are the man!!! I would vote you as the "Super Duper Moderator"
Voon Chan, My post got quality and substance or not? Or did the so called vulgarity used to make my point blinded you and the rest into seeing this post as a XXX material?
Hey Fulat....chill. Btw, cut the religious blabber. You have been doing that since H&C school. Its getting old. And for the record, i do not believe in any faith based religion anymore. Lets set that straight. More power to you if you do.
Bottomline, you and Linkinfark's sexual innuendo is not appropriate here. You both may find it funny, but there are many people who don't. Free speech does not mean you can say anything you want in public.There is place and time for everything, but here, please minimized the use of sexual innuendo's and sexually related materials. Also, this is not a subscription based forum. Da_boss and all the mods are doing this for charity sake. We are not getting any $$ out of it but just the goal of seeing old friends unite. We are not asking much from you both.
My apologies if i see you as not being religious.
Fulat
12-02-2004, 11:22 PM
Hey Fulat....chill. Btw, cut the religious blabber. You have been doing that since H&C school. Its getting old. And for the record, i do not believe in any faith based religion anymore. Lets set that straight. More power to you if you do.
Bottomline, you and Linkinfark's sexual innuendo is not appropriate here. You both may find it funny, but there are many people who don't. Free speech does not mean you can say anything you want in public.There is place and time for everything, but here, please minimized the use of sexual innuendo's and sexually related materials. Also, this is not a subscription based forum. Da_boss and all the mods are doing this for charity sake. We are not getting any $$ out of it but just the goal of seeing old friends unite. We are not asking much from you both.
My apologies if i see you as not being religious.
Brader,
What happened lah? your mother dropped you when you were a kid? hahaha... just kidding ya! still friends ok?
Anyway, self censorship is the best censorship. Porn sites are readily available in the web, if you dont look for it, your wont get to see it. Therefore, if those of you who are offended by the way we write, then dont read, as simple as that. Therefore, do you want to deprive those that enjoy reading our post?
1) If you go to those countries where playboy/penthouse is sold, you can choose not to buy it.
2) If you go to the VCD/DVD shop where porn is sold openly, you can choose not to buy them.
3) If there is a strip joint beside your home, you can choose not to go in.
4) If there is a chicken farm behind your house, you can choose not to go in too.
5) if you dont like to eat KFC, you can eat McD right??
Point made?
Brader,
What happened lah? your mother dropped you when you were a kid? hahaha... just kidding ya! still friends ok?
Anyway, self censorship is the best censorship. Porn sites are readily available in the web, if you dont look for it, your wont get to see it. Therefore, if those of you who are offended by the way we write, then dont read, as simple as that. Therefore, do you want to deprive those that enjoy reading our post?
1) If you go to those countries where playboy/penthouse is sold, you can choose not to buy it.
2) If you go to the VCD/DVD shop where porn is sold openly, you can choose not to buy them.
3) If there is a strip joint beside your home, you can choose not to go in.
4) If there is a chicken farm behind your house, you can choose not to go in too.
5) if you dont like to eat KFC, you can eat McD right??
Point made?
Good point but......nobody smack these things right in front of my face and tell me to buy them. Most people read forum message by message, if yours is slap right in the middle with all the "stuff", people will get offended. Even in DVD stores, porn has a section for it. They don't smack right in front of the store for people to see.
Point made??
cireria
12-02-2004, 11:55 PM
Hi Fulat/Dino,
You've both made your points. There's a possible solution to this - a restricted area in the forum where contents not viewable by public. Access will not be automatic even if you're a forum member, i.e. access granted to forum members on individual application basis (we need to know who you are). Thus if you're in there, you know what to expect and willingly participate in the action... As always, will need to run the idea through the Administrator.
Hi Fulat/Dino,
You've both made your points. There's a possible solution to this - a restricted area in the forum where contents not viewable by public. Access will not be automatic even if you're a forum member, i.e. access granted to forum members on individual application basis (we need to know who you are). Thus if you're in there, you know what to expect and willingly participate in the action... As always, will need to run the idea through the Administrator.
Yup, thats what i proposed earlier that there be a section for members who are more open to these things.
daBoss
12-03-2004, 01:34 AM
Hi Fulat/Dino,
You've both made your points. There's a possible solution to this - a restricted area in the forum where contents not viewable by public. Access will not be automatic even if you're a forum member, i.e. access granted to forum members on individual application basis (we need to know who you are). Thus if you're in there, you know what to expect and willingly participate in the action... As always, will need to run the idea through the Administrator.good suggestion - i'll try to set it up asap - problem is i have a real headache in a project at work now and am struggling to find time.
decision has been made - no profanities. a couple of 'kok' or 'ass' here and there i'm willing to accept. nothing more colorful than that.
i'll take actions if i have to spend too much time editing.
[THREAD CLOSED] Please don't open another similar one.
vBulletin® v3.8.5, Copyright ©2000-2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.